Best Corkscrew for Old Corks

Natural corks allow for air to breathe. This is what causes wine to age regularly and become higher-quality. That’s why corks have long been preferred for sealing bottles of wine in storage.

There is a downside to corks, though. As they allow wine to age and become more delicious, they also age themselves. Corks can become porous and crumble easily, which makes it difficult to remove them intact.

You don’t want to pour your glass of wine, only to find little bits of cork floating in it. That’s sure to ruin the mood.

There are a number of potential solutions to this problem. A few different tools are available to help you deal with old corks in the most efficient manner possible.

Regular corkscrews aren’t always the best choice when you’re removing old corks. When they pierce the cork, they can cause it to crumble and fall into the wine. Instead, you’ll want to invest in a cork puller.

Cork pullers take a little more work to use. Rather than popping the cork out, you gently slide it out of the bottle. But because they’re more gentle, they’re also much more likely to remove the cork in one piece.

If you do run into trouble with a crumbling cork, don’t worry! There are also cork retrievers on the market. These nifty devices help you fish the cork out of your wine bottle, so you don’t have to pull pieces of cork out of your glass.

Comparison Table

Brand NameDimensionsMaterialNotes
#1. Corkfish Wine
Best Cork Retriever

Check Price
11 x 3.5 inchesStainless steelTube handle hides synthetic mesh
#2. Cork Retriever 1030

Check Price
10.1 x 2.8 inchesStainless steelRetrieves corks in wine bottles
#3. Monopol Westmark
Best Cork Puller

Check Price
4.3 x 2.6 inchesSteel2 prongs
#4. Norpro A2B Cork Puller

Check Price
5 x 1.5 inchesStainless steelComes with sheath cover

Best Corkscrew Retrievers for Crumbling Old Corks

#1. Corkfish Wine Cork Retriever

Check Price

If you’re dealing with crumbly old wine corks, this cork retriever is one of the best options. It can fish out a crumbling cork that’s floating in your wine bottle. The simple design is made out of stainless steel. A basket is attached to the handle, allowing you to “fish” your wine corks. All you have to do is lower the basket into the bottle and scoop the pieces of the cork inside.

Even if cork pieces have only been in your wine once or twice, you know how pesky they can be. The Corkfish takes all the hassle out of removing them. In addition, the retriever has a handy mesh component that helps you fish out smaller cork pieces. Since the mesh is stored inside the hollow handle, you won’t lose it by accident.

This handy gadget should definitely be part of your wine drinking toolkit, alongside your corkscrew and foil cutter.

#2. Cork Retriever 1030

Check Price

This cork retriever has the same basic principle as the Corkfish, but the design has a few differences. The long stainless steel fingers have a plastic handle attached. You just use the plastic handle to remove pieces of cork from your wine bottle.

The biggest difference between the two cork retrievers is that this retriever doesn’t come with a net. This means that fishing out tiny fragments might be more difficult. It’s only designed to fish out whole wine corks, rather than pieces of them.

This is a good tool for avid wine drinkers, but it may not be as effective as the Corkfish when it comes to old and crumbling wine corks.

#3. Monopol Westmark Germany Steel Cork Puller

Check Price

When you’re pulling an old cork, using the right tool means that hopefully you won’t need a cork retriever. This cork puller is an ideal option because of its 2-prong design. 2-prong cork pullers tend to be better than regular corkscrews when you’re dealing with old corks.

This cork puller comes with two steel prongs, along with a die-cast handle. The puller fetches the cork from the bottle without damaging it. In addition, the handle can be used as a bottle opener. It’s covered with decorative casing.

This tool is easy to use, efficient, and reliable. It also has a five year warranty, so you’re covered should it become faulty for any reason. The beautiful cover protects the sharp prongs to allow safe storage.

#4. Norpro A2B Cork Puller

Check Price

This cork puller is another ideal option if you want a high quality design that doesn’t break the bank.

The overall design is different from the previous cork puller. However, both items operate on the same principle. This cork puller features prongs of equal length. They’re blunt enough to keep you from piercing the cork. The cover also protects the prongs, so you don’t accidentally stab yourself.

The puller is made from stainless steel and manufactured in Italy.

The Fancy Option

If crumbled cork ends up in your wine, there’s a fancier option for removing it than using a cork retriever. You’ll use a wine funnel that has a strainer, along with a gorgeous decanter. This method is better for use at home than when you’re out at your favorite restaurant.

You place the funnel in the mouth of your decanter and carefully pour the wine. The strainer will catch any pieces of cork that are floating inside, ensuring you’re left with delicious and smooth wine.

Final Thoughts

When you’re dealing with an old cork, you want to have several tools at your disposal.

The best cork retriever is the Corkfish. It can fish out both whole and crumbling corks, ensuring you don’t have little pieces floating in your wine.

The best cork puller is the Monopol. It’s designed to carefully remove the cork from the wine bottle, so that hopefully it won’t crumble in the first place.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.